Are You Making These Common Holiday Fitness Mistakes? (Portland Maine Gym Owner Reveals All)

Evan Amell • December 15, 2025

Hey there! It's that time of year again... December's here, and I can already see it happening at EA Fitness & Performance. You know what I'm talking about, right?


The holiday season rolls around, and suddenly everyone's fitness routine goes out the window faster than a kid tearing into presents on Christmas morning.


As someone who's been helping folks in Portland, Maine stay fit for years, I've seen the same mistakes happen over and over again. And honestly? It breaks my heart a little because most of these pitfalls are totally avoidable.



So let's talk about it. Here are the biggest holiday fitness mistakes I see people making every December – and more importantly, how you can avoid them.

Mistake #1: Going Full Grinch and Skipping Workouts Completely

This is the big one. The granddaddy of all holiday fitness mistakes.

You're stressed, you're busy, the gym has weird holiday hours, and suddenly you think, "You know what? I'll just take a break until January 1st."


Stop.



I get it – the holidays are crazy. But here's the thing: your body doesn't take a vacation just because it's December. When you combine skipping workouts with all those extra cookies, eggnog, and holiday dinners... well, you're setting yourself up for a rough January.


The fix: Don't aim for perfection – aim for consistency. Even 20 minutes, two times a week is infinitely better than zero minutes, zero times a week. Your future self will thank you.

At our gym, we actually see our most successful members during the holidays. Want to know their secret? They show up. Not every day, not for two-hour sessions, but they show up consistently.

Mistake #2: Overambitious Planning (The "Holiday Hero" Syndrome)

On the flip side, some of you go completely overboard in the other direction. You look at your calendar and think, "Okay, I'm going to work out five times a week, meal prep every Sunday, and somehow become the fittest version of myself by New Year's."

Here's what usually happens with this approach: You plan these amazing workouts, but then life happens. Your sister needs you to help with Christmas shopping. Your office holiday party runs late. The kids have a snow day.


Suddenly, you've missed three workouts in a row, you feel like a failure, and you give up entirely.


The reality check: December is not the month for your most ambitious fitness goals. It's the month for being smart, strategic, and sustainable.


The fix: Plan for 2-3 workouts per week max. Make them count, but make them realistic. I tell my clients to aim for two solid small group training sessions per week during December. It's manageable, effective, and you'll actually stick to it.

Mistake #3: The All-or-Nothing Cardio Trap

Every December, I see people abandon their strength training and go all-in on cardio.The thinking is: "I'm eating more, so I need to burn more calories, so I'll just run on the treadmill for an hour every day."


Here's the problem with this approach – it's not sustainable, and it's not even that effective.


When you ditch strength training completely, you lose muscle mass. When you lose muscle mass, your metabolism slows down. When your metabolism slows down, you actually burn fewer calories throughout the day.


The better approach: Keep strength training as your foundation. Yes, add some extra cardio if you want, but don't make it your entire routine.


Our personal training clients who maintain their strength routines through the holidays? They come back in January stronger than when they left. The ones who switch to cardio-only? They're starting from scratch.

Mistake #4: Perfectionist Eating (The "I'll Start Monday" Mentality)

This one drives me absolutely nuts because I see it destroy people's progress every single year.

Here's how it goes: You eat a piece of pie at the office party on Tuesday. Instead of just moving on, you think, "Well, I already messed up today, might as well eat whatever I want for the rest of the week. I'll get back on track Monday."

So Tuesday becomes a write-off. Wednesday becomes a write-off. The whole week becomes a write-off.


The truth: One piece of pie isn't going to ruin your fitness goals. But seven days of "I already messed up" thinking absolutely will.


The mindset shift: Every meal is a fresh start. Every snack is a chance to make a good choice. You don't have to wait until Monday, or January 1st, or any other arbitrary date.

Mistake #5: Ignoring Sleep and Stress Management

I know, I know – sleep isn't technically "fitness." But here's the thing: if you're not sleeping well, everything else falls apart.

December is stressful. Shopping, cooking, family dynamics, end-of-year work deadlines... it all adds up.


When you're stressed and sleep-deprived, your body produces more cortisol. More cortisol means more cravings for sugary, high-calorie foods. It also makes it harder to build muscle and easier to store fat.


The fix: Treat sleep like it's part of your fitness routine. Aim for 7-8 hours. Create a bedtime routine. Put your phone away an hour before bed.


And stress management? That's where exercise actually helps. A good workout is one of the best stress relievers you can find.

Mistake #6: Traveling Without a Plan

Whether you're visiting family in Boston or taking the kids to see relatives down south, travel can completely derail your fitness routine. But here's what I tell my clients: you don't need a full gym to stay active.


Smart travel strategies:

  • Pack resistance bands (they take up zero space)
  • Use bodyweight exercises in your hotel room
  • Walk whenever possible
  • Find a local gym with day passes
  • Use hotel fitness centers (even if they're basic)

The goal isn't to maintain your exact routine – it's to maintain the habit of moving your body.

The Portland Maine Advantage: Community Support

You know what I love about our community here in Portland? We support each other.



This is why I'm such a big believer in small group training during the holidays. When you're working out with other people who have the same challenges – busy schedules, holiday stress, family obligations – you realize you're not alone in this.


Plus, there's built-in accountability. When Sarah knows you're supposed to be at the 6 AM session on Wednesday, you're way more likely to show up than if you're trying to motivate yourself to work out alone in your basement.

What Success Really Looks Like

Here's the thing about holiday fitness – success isn't about losing weight in December. Success isn't about setting new personal records.



Success is showing up consistently, even when it's hard. Success is making the best choice available to you in each moment. Success is getting to January 2nd and not feeling like you have to "start over."


When you avoid these common mistakes, you get to January feeling strong, confident, and ready to take your fitness to the next level. You don't have to spend the first month of the new year just trying to get back to where you were in November.

Ready to Make This Your Best Holiday Season Yet?

If you're tired of the same old cycle – struggling through the holidays, feeling guilty in January, spending months getting back to where you started – let's change that pattern.


Whether you're interested in personal training or want to try our supportive small group training environment, we're here to help you navigate the holidays without sacrificing your health and fitness goals.


The holidays don't have to be a fitness disaster. With the right approach, they can actually be a time when you prove to yourself just how committed you are to taking care of yourself.


Ready to make it happen? Get in touch with us and let's create a plan that works for your life, your schedule, and your goals.

You've got this! 💪

recent posts

July 27, 2026
Improve your golf game with TPI training. Address physical limitations for better performance. Join us at EA Fitness & Performance!
By Evan Amell July 22, 2026
If you’re one of the many residents here in Southern Maine who has started a GLP-1 medication like Ozempic, Wegovy, or Zepbound, you’ve likely felt a mix of relief and excitement. For many, these medications feel like a long-awaited breakthrough: a way to finally quiet the "food noise" and see the scale move after years of frustration. But as the weight begins to drop, there’s a critical conversation happening in the medical and fitness world that you need to hear. It’s not just about how much weight you’re losing; it’s about what kind of weight is leaving your body. Here’s the reality: without a dedicated plan, a significant portion of the weight you lose on these medications isn’t fat. It’s muscle. And for those of us over 40, losing muscle isn't just a vanity issue: it’s a direct threat to our long-term health, metabolism, and independence. At EA Fitness & Performance , we’ve seen how transformative these medications can be when paired with the right strategy. But we’ve also seen the "Ozempic look": the loss of muscle tone and energy that happens when weight loss is unsupported. Let’s talk about why strength training is no longer just "good for you": it’s a non-negotiable part of your medical journey. 🏋️‍♀️ The "Muscle Gap": What the Data Really Says When you lose weight through traditional dieting, it's normal for a small percentage of that weight to come from lean tissue. However, the rapid weight loss triggered by GLP-1 medications can significantly accelerate this process. Research from various clinical trials shows that 20% to 50% of the weight lost on GLP-1s can come from lean muscle mass. To put that in perspective: if you lose 40 pounds, you might be losing 10 to 20 pounds of pure muscle. For someone over 40, that is a staggering figure. Some experts have noted that the muscle loss experienced over a single year on these medications can be equivalent to 20 years of age-related muscle decline. Think about that for a second... Do you really want to age your body two decades in the span of 12 months just to see a smaller number on the scale? Probably not. Muscle is the foundation of your physical "house." If you’re tearing down the foundation to reduce the weight of the roof, the whole structure becomes unstable. Why Muscle is Your "Longevity Superpower" You might be thinking, "Evan, I just want to fit into my old jeans. Why does muscle matter so much?" It matters because muscle is much more than just something that looks good in a t-shirt. It is your most active metabolic organ. 1. It Protects Your Metabolism 📈 Muscle burns more calories at rest than fat does. When you lose muscle, your Basal Metabolic Rate (BMR) drops. This means your body requires fewer calories to maintain its weight. This is the primary reason why so many people experience "rebound" weight gain after they stop a diet or medication. If you've lost your muscle, your "engine" has essentially shrunk, making it incredibly easy to gain fat back later. 2. It Secures Your Bone Density 🦴 For our clients in the 40+ demographic, bone health is everything. When you carry less weight, your bones have less "load" on them, which can lead to a decrease in bone density. Strength training provides the necessary mechanical stress to keep your bones strong and resilient against fractures. 3. It Maintains Your Independence 🚶‍♂️ Muscle is what allows you to hike the trails at Bradbury Mountain, carry your groceries, and pick up your grandkids. Losing muscle leads to frailty, balance issues, and a loss of the lifestyle you’ve worked so hard to build here in Maine. The Solution: The EA Fitness & Performance Approach You don't have to choose between losing weight and staying strong. You can: and should: do both. At EA Fitness & Performance , we specialize in helping adults over 40 navigate these exact challenges through a collaborative approach to wellness. Stop trying to figure this out on your own. Our Personal Training and Small Group Personal Training programs are designed specifically to counteract the muscle loss associated with rapid weight loss. We don't just give you a "workout"; we give you a prescription for longevity. How we help you bridge the gap: Customized Loading: We ensure you are lifting heavy enough to stimulate muscle growth (hypertrophy) without overtaxing your joints. Form First: Our expert coaches, including myself and Coach Andy Goyet , ensure every rep is safe and effective. Accountability: It’s easy to skip the gym when you’re feeling the fatigue that sometimes comes with GLP-1s. We provide the community and support to keep you showing up. The Nutrition Factor: Protein is Your Best Friend Lifting weights is only half the battle. If you aren't giving your body the building blocks it needs to repair that muscle, the training won't stick. One of the side effects of GLP-1s is a suppressed appetite. While this helps with weight loss, it often means people aren't eating enough protein. When your body is in a caloric deficit and doesn't get enough protein, it will harvest that protein from your own muscle tissue. We recommend prioritizing protein at every single meal. 🥩🥗 Our Nutrition Coaching helps you create a sustainable eating plan that supports your medication's effects while protecting your lean mass. We focus on "Protein First" strategies that ensure you’re fueled for your workouts and your life. Your 3-Step GLP-1 Strength Protocol If you’re currently on a GLP-1, or considering starting one, here is your checklist for success: Strength Train 2–3 Times Per Week: Focus on compound movements like squats, rows, and presses. These give you the most "bang for your buck" and involve multiple muscle groups. ✅ Hit Your Protein Targets: Aim for roughly 0.8 to 1 gram of protein per pound of target body weight. If that sounds like a lot, don't worry: our coaches can help you find easy ways to get there. ✅ Track Your Progress (Not Just the Scale): At EA, we look at how much you're lifting and how you're feeling, not just what the floor scale says. Strength gains are a better indicator of health than just weight loss. ✅ Don't Just Lose Weight: Gain Life Weight loss is a great goal, but it shouldn't come at the expense of your vitality. You deserve to be lean, strong, and capable of enjoying everything Southern Maine has to offer. Don’t let your medication "eat" your muscle. Take control of your transformation by putting strength training at the center of your plan. Whether you’re a complete beginner or a seasoned athlete, our team is here to guide you every step of the way. We pride ourselves on our welcoming, supportive community where you can feel comfortable and confident while you work toward your goals. Ready to protect your muscle and supercharge your results? Click here to learn more about our Personal Training programs or contact us today to schedule a consultation. Let’s make sure your weight loss journey is a healthy one. Stay strong, Evan Amell Owner, EA Fitness & Performance
July 20, 2026
Let’s be honest for a second... the fitness industry is kind of a mess.  If you’ve spent any time looking for a way to get back in shape, you’ve probably been bombarded with "30-day shreds," "magic" detox teas, and influencers telling you that if you just work hard enough, you’ll look like a twenty-something again. It’s exhausting, isn't it? You’re constantly told to push harder, eat less, and follow a cookie-cutter plan that wasn't actually built for you. And if you’re over 40? Most of those programs don't even consider how your body has changed, how your joints feel, or how busy your actual life is. At EA Fitness & Performance , we saw this gap and decided to do things differently. We’re not here to sell you a quick fix that leaves you burnt out and back at square one by next month. We’re here to change the way you think about fitness for good.